Watch: Andy Cohen, Ex John Hill Laugh About Their 'Bad' Sex Tape from 2003

Andy Cohen and his "Watch What Happens Live" guests enjoyed a laugh with Cohen's ex (and guest bartender) John Hill over a sex tape Cohen and Hill supposedly made in 2003 – though, Cohen says, "it's on some janky format."

Hill disclosed the tape's existence as he ticked through a list of "Things Andy Should Do in 2025" that also included the suggestion that Cohen should "get tits," "learn to read," and give Hill a raise for his co-hosting duties on Cohen's radio show "Andy Cohen Live!"

Mention of the sex tape provoked titters from Cohen's guests, Erika Jayne (of "Real Housewives of Beverly Hill") and Racquel Chevremont (a cast member of the not-yet-premiered "Real Housewives of New York City"), as well as from Cohen himself.

"Wait, I kind of want to see it!" Jayne said, while Chevremont cried, "Can we pull it up?"

"I think there is one," Cohen confessed, "but the format – it's on some janky format."

Hill, grinning, just shook his head. "It's bad," he agreed.

"No, I'm glad," Cohen added. "We probably can't even transfer it."

Not that anyone necessarily believed that. Jayne certainly didn't: "Yes we can!" she insisted.

Watch the moment in the clip below.

"The pair dated for three years in the early 2000s," Entertainment Weekly recalled in a writeup about the exchange, "a subject that's come up more than once during Hill's past 'WWHL' appearances."

During the time they dated, Hill "was still a part of the original Broadway cast of 'Hairspray,'" People Magazine filled in.

"Cohen and Hill have previously discussed their sex tape," EW said. "At Hill's 'The Feels Live' show in 2020, Cohen dished, 'There is a sex tape of us floating around somewhere.'"

"When an audience member asked why the pair broke up," EW noted, "Hill said it 'was just time,' and Cohen added, 'We were in different places in our lives.'"